At St Kilda post-1925

Player	Seasons at Carlton	Seasons at St Kilda	Other Clubs
George Robbins	1925, 1929	1921–1924	Footscray
Harry McPherson	1925–1926	1928	Nil
Percy Outram	1925–1927	1928–1930	Nil
Vin Arthur	1927–1933	1926–1927	Nil
Ansell Clarke	1929–1937	1938–1940	Nil
Eric Little	1931–1934	1935	Nil
Les Hughson	1933–1934	1934–1936	Collingwood, Hawthorn
Clem Neeson	1936–1937	1937	Nil
Lance Regnier	1941	1939–1940	Nil
Allan Greenshields	1947–1949	1949–1954	Nil
Brian Molony	1952–1955	1956–1958	Nil
Bruce McMaster-Smith	1962–1964	1965	Fitzroy
Neil Chandler	1968–1974	1974	Nil
Bill Barrot	1971	1971	Richmond
Rod Galt	1975–1979	1971–1974	Nil
Peter Brown	1976–1980	1981–1982	Nil
Peter McConville	1978–1985	1986–1989	Nil
Alex Marcou	1979–1986	1987–1988	Nil
Alex Jesaulenko	1967–1979	1980–1981	Nil
Ken Sheldon	1977–1986	1987–1989	Nil
Peter Fitzpatrick	1978, 1980	1980	Nil
Warren 'Wow' Jones	1978–1985	1986–1988	Nil
Val Perovic	1980–1985	1973–1979	Nil
Greg Sharp	1981, 1983	1984	Nil
Spiro Kourkoumelis	1981–1986	1987–1990	Nil
Mark Buckley	1982–1985	1985	Brisbane
Ricky Nixon	1983–1985	1986–1991	Hawthorn
Ian Muller	1984–1985	1988–1991	Nil
Ian Aitken	1987–1992	1993	Nil
Mark Arceri	1991–1992	1993	North Melbourne
Dean Rice	1994–2001	1987–1993	Nil
Craig Devonport	1996	1989–1995	Nil
Sean Charles	1998	2000	Melbourne
Sam Cranage	2001–2002	1998–2000	Nil
Aaron Hamill	1995–2000	2001–2007	Nil
Matthew Lappin	1999–2007	1994–1998	Nil
Cain Ackland	2007–2008	2005–2006	Port Adelaide
Nick Heyne	2012	2010–2011	Nil
Hugh Goddard	2019–2020	2015–2018	Nil
Sam Rowe	2013–2018	2019	Nil
Jack Newnes	2020–2022	2012–2019	Nil
Blake Acres	2023–Present	2014–2019	Fremantle
Liam Stocker	2019–2022	2023–Present	Nil
Paddy Dow	2018–2023	2024–Present	Nil
Jack Carroll	2021–2024	2025–Present	Nil
Tom De Koning	2018–2025	2026–Present	Nil
Jack Silvagni	2016–2025	2026–Present	Nil